As shown schematically in Figure 1, spatial autocorrelation statistics are used to measure how the value of a parameter at one point (voxel) in space is related to the same parameter at varying spatial distances. Spatial autocorrelation statistics are calculated by pairing each sampled voxel or group of voxels successively with all other voxel locations and recording the parameter value associated with each location pair along with the distance between the two samples to generate a list of data in the form distance, value1, value2. After each spatial location has been paired with all other locations, data with similar distances between samples are grouped together. The data within each bin are treated as paired observations and linearly correlated, producing a correlation coefficient for that "bin" or "distance."
In our previous studies of pulmonary blood flow distribution, we found that the spatial location along the gravity vector defines only 50% +10%(SD)of the spatial heterogeneity supine and 40% +10%(SD) prone and the coefficient of variation measuring spatial heterogeneity was 31% across all body postures. We were unable to demonstrate a radial gradient close to the magnitude found by Hakim. If one invokes a role for vascular conductance and vascular geometry in determining pulmonary blood flow distribution, the minimal presence of a radial distribution pattern is not surprising: vascular branching, particularly in species other than humans, is not radially oriented. From these observations along with our observations regarding regional lung air content and regional differences in alveolar expansion with lung inflation, we hypothesized that regional air content and regional pulmonary perfusion have two non-overlapping determinants: 1) gravity and support of the heart, and 2) vascular conductance respectively. An interesting additional finding from our data to date has been that there is a strong and similar correlation between regional lung air content and the regional blood content of the lung, thus implying either a causal relationship between these two parameters or a common determinant. With an interest in evaluating the utility of the spatial autocorrelation construct in furthering our hypothesis testing, we have undertaken an evaluation of the spatial autocorrelation statistic, and have applied it to the various regional lung function parameters which are derived from time-intensity curves obtained via use of Electron Beam x-ray CT (EBCT: Imatron Corp, South San Francisco) scanning10.

The output of the program is a text file listing distance, correlation coefficient, and number of pairs for each non-empty bin. The distance reported is from the center of each non-empty bin. The correlation coefficient (r) reported for each bin/distance is used to generate graphs of correlation (r) vs. distance (cm) for each parameter from the supine and prone body positions and also for the computer generated models. For our CT-derived data, only regions within the same lobe (lower left lobe as approximated by user-interactive editing of the image data using VIDA) were correlated. The lower left lobe was used as this was the least challenging in terms of separating the lobe from other lobes using the 8mm thick EBCT high temporal resolution image data sets.

Compared to the random population cube, the pure gradient simulations exhibit a different correlation-distance relationship. The gradient cubes display a high positive correlation for nearby samples that decays as distance increases, with the correlation coefficient becoming increasingly negative as distance increases (Figures 2 & 3). This negative correlation at greater distances is similar to that observed by Glenny8.
To test for the effects of shape on the spatial autocorrelation pattern, we analyzed pyramids and 3-d wedges with either pure x, y, or z gradients. Though the correlation-distance data from the 3-d wedges and cubes are from two distinct structures, they both show a similar correlation-distance relationship (Figure 4). In the case of the 3-d wedge, two simulations (x and y gradients) yielded identical results while the third (z gradient) simulation shows a slightly altered relationship relative to the other two. Although there is greater scatter in the data, the pyramid models display similar correlation vs. distance relationships to the cubes and wedges.
We also applied pure x, y, or z gradients to the three dimensional voxel coordinates of the left lower lobe from the supine and prone body postures. Again, there are high, positive correlations for nearby regions that become increasingly negative as the distances between regions increase. The results are not identical for the three gradient directions within a given body posture, and the correlation-distance relationship is the most consistent between the prone and supine posture for the y gradients, which correspond to the direction of the gravitational field in our experimental data sets. While the lobe changes shape from the supine to prone positions, the spatial correlation patterns for a given applied gradient direction remain nearly identical for the two body postures. It appears, therefore, that an object's shape has little influence on the correlation vs. distance relationship. Moreover, the increasingly negative correlation over larger distances is generated by gravitational effects alone. The altered pattern for the z gradient in our lobe data set might be explained by the reduced resolution in the z axis due to the 8 mm slice thickness.
We followed the computer model autocorrelation analysis by applying spatial autocorrelation statistics to our x-ray CT derived regional structural and functional parameters of the pulmonary system. Autocorrelation analysis was done for the following nine parameters from the left lower lobe in both the supine and prone postures: regional air, blood and tissue percentages; regional arrival, mean transit, and peak times; regional raw blood flow and regional blood flow normalized to tissue or air content. The results reported here are from the left lower lobes of six canines imaged in the supine and prone body postures. Dogs were anesthetized with sodium pentobarbital and Inovar. Guidelines governing the care and treatment of animals issued by the NIH were adhered to and study permission was obtained from the institutional animal care and use committee.

Regional air content autocorrelation plots show a steep negative correlation vs. distance relationship supine which is significantly reduced or eliminated (essentially remaining flat around zero correlation for all distance) in the prone posture (figure 5, upper left). The regional air content autocorrelation plots of data from the supine posture display a similar correlation vs. distance pattern to those from the pure gravity gradient cubes (see figure 2) and particularly to the simulated lobar gravity gradient shown in figure 4, center bottom panel, suggesting that regional air content may be influenced by gravitational effects (such as the lung's support of the heart) supine while gravitational effects are reduced or eliminated in the prone posture (such as by a shift in support of the heart weight from the lungs to the sternum).
For all dogs, the spatial correlation of regional tissue content follows a closely similar pattern across the supine and prone body postures. However, in the instances where the autocorrelation graphs for tissue content are not similar for the two body postures (one dog), the supine plot showed an enhanced negative correlation-distance relationship relative to the prone posture (figure 5, lower left). Similarly, regional blood content is either posture independent or shows an enhanced negative correlation-distance relationship supine relative to the prone body posture. This is similar to the findings related to regional air content (figure 5, upper right vs. upper left). Mean transit time appears to exhibit the least spatial correlation (negative and positive) over all distance in both the supine and prone postures (figure 5, lower right).

Contrary to regional air content, the correlation vs. distance relationship for regional pulmonary perfusion normalized to tissue content appears nearly identical supine vs. prone (figure 6). In one dog, however, there is an enhanced negative relationship prone vs. supine. (figure 6, right). The correlation-distance relationship of regional pulmonary perfusion/tissue is not as steep as seen with regional air content; and the slope is significantly reduced, with a flattened appearance. Regional peak time follows a pattern similar to perfusion/tissue for most (4/6) dogs (data not shown).

We noticed a significant difference in spatial correlation supine vs. prone when regional perfusion was normalized to air content rather than tissue content (figure 7). This normalization may be closer to the normalization factor utilized by Glenny and others who analyze their data using the excised air dried lung. Perfusion normalized to regional air content generates similar supine to prone differences across all dogs, reminiscent of the regional air content autocorrelation plots (see figure 5, upper left). Regional raw blood flow (not normalized to air or tissue content) is steeper supine vs. prone in nearly every dog, apparently following a spatial correlation pattern similar to air content.
Regional arrival time remains essentially uncorrelated over distance in all dogs and postures with the entire lobe maximally enhanced at the same point in time.
The results from the computer generated models demonstrate that a negative correlation-distance relationship is not unique. Data sets of multiple shapes which show a spatial distribution of a given parameter along a single axis exhibit negative spatial

correlation as a function of distance. The correlation vs. distance slopes are steeper for the computer simulations as compared to our CT-derived experimental data. This may be due to our methodology in generating the model data. In the gradient simulations, we set "flow" equal to the voxel location (i.e. for y gradients, all voxels with identical y locations had identical values) rather than reflecting gradient magnitudes similar to the experimental data. The simulated gradients used are steeper than the experimental data, therefore, leading to a steeper correlation-distance relationship. Forcing the gradient range of the simulations to match the range of actual PBF gradients may alter the slope of the spatial correlation relationship to that more similar to the experimental data.
It should be noted that, in our studies of in vivo lung function, we may not have been completely successful in separating out, digitally, a single lung lobe. We chose to study the left lung because of the fewer lobulations, and we chose to study the lower lobe because of its large ventral-dorsal expanse in the region just above the diaphragm. However, it should be noted that in our previous studies, the left lung shows a greater variability in spatial relationships as compared with the right lung. We have, in the past again attributed this to the support of the heart by the lung. When apparent zone 4 conditions14 are present, resulting in decreased flow to the dependent lung regions, this almost always appears most prominent in the left lower lobe15. The variability demonstrated in the pair of graphs shown in figure 6 may very well be due to our selection of the left lower lobe.
Our model data, contrary to the actual flow data reported by Glenny, reflects a relationship best fit by an exponential such as:

Similarly, our air content data, as well as the blood content data, and pulmonary blood flow normalized to air content spatial autocorrelation relationships all were best fit to an exponential relationship in the supine body posture. An exponential fit has also been found by Rodarte and colleagues when using a spatial correlation statistic to evaluate CT density distribution16. Spatial autocorrelation data for the prone body posture regardless of parameter being evaluated, and regional tissue content and mean transit times both supine and prone come closer to fitting a power law relationship. Of particular interest is the fact that blood flow normalized to tissue content rather than air content comes closer to reflecting data presented by Glenny. Normalization is a significant unknown when comparing our finding with those of others. Our data sets are fairly unique in that the information is evaluated in vivo. By excision and air drying the lung at total lung capacity (25cmH2O), normalization under these conditions may yield quite a different relationship. Normalization itself can impose a structure to the assessed distribution of function, and this is an important area for further thought. In figure 8 we show our blood flow data from a representative dog where flow is normalized to regional air content. Superimposed on the supine and prone spatial autocorrelation relationship for this dog are the power law based fits for the dogs studied in Glenny's experiments. While the slope of the prone data from our study is considerably more shallow, the shape of the relationship comes closer to fitting with Glenny's data than is the supine relationship. Our supine data, normalized in this fashion is considerably at odds with that of Glenny. In this case, our data closer reflects the pure, single gradient artificially imposed upon the lower lobe coordinates and shown in the lower, central panel of figure 4.

We have previously demonstrated that, while there is a significant difference in the height dependence of both pulmonary blood flow and regional lung air content supine versus prone, the relationship between the regional air/blood ratio and lung height remains nearly constant across body postures15. This may be demonstrating that as alveoli expand, regional blood volume is reduced. The close similarity between the two plots at the top of figure 5 nicely demonstrate this relationship through the use of the spatial autocorrelation approach. The flattening of the spatial autocorrelation plot for tissue content seen in the lower left panel of figure 5 may reflect that tissue remains more constant across lung regions while air and blood remains tied to each other through an inverse relationship.
2. Hoffman, E.A, "Effect of body orientation on regional lung expansion: A computed tomographic approach," Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 59, pp.468-480, 1985.
3. Hoffman, E.A., and E.L. Ritman, "Effect of body orientation on regional lung expansion in dog and sloth," Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 59, pp. 481-491, 1985.
4. Larsen, R.L., C.R. Bridges, K.C. Beck, and E.A. Hoffman, "Regional Pulmonary Blood Flow Via Cine X-ray Computed Tomography," The FASEB Journal, Vol.4, pp. A1074, 1990.
5. Glenny, R.W., W.J. Lamm, R.K. Albert and H.T. Robertson, "Gravity is a minor determinant of pulmonary blood flow distribution," Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 71, pp. 620-629, 1991.
6. Beck, K.C., and K. Rehder, "Differences in regional vascular conductances in isolated dog lungs," Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 61, pp. 530-538, 1986.
7. Glenny, R.W., and H.T. Robertson, "Fractal properties of pulmonary blood flow: characterization of spatial heterogeneity," Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 69, pp. 532-545, 1990.
8. Glenny, R.W., "Spatial correlation of regional pulmonary perfusion," Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 72, pp. 2378-2386, 1992.
9. Griffith, D.A. Spatial Autocorrelation. A Primer. Commercial Printing, State College, PA, 1987.
10. Tajik J.K., S.D. Kugelmass, and E.A. Hoffman, "An automated method for relating regional pulmonary structure and function: integration of dynamic multislice CT and thin-slice high-resolution CT," SPIE Proceedings,Vol. 1905 , pp. 339-350, 1993.
11. Boyd, D.P., and M.J. Lipton, "Cardiac computed tomography," Proceedings of the IEEE, Vol.71, pp.298-307, 1983.
12. Hoffman, E.A., J.K. Tajik, and S.D. Kugelmass, "Matching pulmonary structure and perfusion via combined dynamic multislice CT and thin-slice high-resolution CT," Computerized Medical Imaging and Graphics, In Press, 1994.
13. Hoffman, E.A., D. Gnanaprakasam, K.B. Gupta, J.D. Hoford, S.D. Kugelmass, and R.S. Kulawiec, "VIDA: An environment for multidimensional image display and analysis," SPIE Proceedings, Vol. 1660, pp. 694-711, 1992.
14. West , J.B., Respiratory Physiology-the essentials (4th ed.). Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, 1990.
15. Hoffman, E.A., and J.K. Tajik, "Dynamic and high resolution CT assessment of pulmonary blood flow distribution," American Review of Respiratory Disease, Vol. 147, No. 4, pp. A1021, 1993.
16. Rodarte, J.R., M. Chaniotakis, and T.A. Wilson, "Variability of parenchymal expansion measured by computed tomography," Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 67, pp. 226-231, 1989.
Papers |
DPI Homepage |
VIDA |
NLM |
Contact Us |
Search